Tailor Brands

Home » LLC Formation » LLC Comparisons » LLC vs. S Corp

When starting a business, you have many decisions to make, and one is choosing a structure. An LLC is a common choice because it offers many benefits to small business owners. As profits grow, though, so does the self-employment tax bill.

That’s why many LLC owners look at S corp status. An LLC and an S corp have important similarities, such as pass-through taxation. But they also have significant differences that affect how much tax you pay and how you pay it. This guide covers what each one is, how they differ and how to choose.

LLC vs. S corp at a glance

ItemLLC (default taxation)S corp
What it isA legal entity formed with the stateA federal tax election made on IRS Form 2553
Who can use itAnyone forming a businessEligible LLCs and corporations
OwnersNo limit; individuals or entities, U.S. or foreignUp to 100 eligible shareholders (individuals, certain trusts and estates)
How owners are paidDraws or distributionsReasonable salary plus distributions
Self-employment taxOn the owner’s share of net earningsPayroll taxes on salary only; distributions aren’t subject to them
Profit splitsFlexible, set in the operating agreementIn proportion to ownership
Added costsState fees and annual reportsPayroll, a separate Form 1120-S return and often higher accounting fees

What is an S corporation?

An S corporation is a tax classification, not one of the business entities you form with your state. Before you can become an S corp, you must first create an LLC or a corporation and then file Form 2553 with the IRS.

S corporations (and LLCs by default) are pass-through entities. Profits pass through to the owners’ tax returns, avoiding federal corporate income tax and double taxation.

LLC owners with steady profits often elect S corp taxation to reduce their self-employment tax bill. The owner takes a reasonable salary, which is subject to payroll taxes, and can take remaining profits as distributions that aren’t subject to payroll or self-employment tax.

To qualify, the IRS requires the business to be a domestic entity with no more than 100 shareholders, only one class of stock, and only allowable shareholders. Shareholders can be individuals, certain trusts and estates. They can’t be partnerships, corporations or nonresident aliens.

What is an LLC?

An LLC is a legal business structure that provides liability protection to its owners, protecting their personal assets in cases of business debt or litigation.

There are several types of LLCs. Two of the main ones are a single-member LLC, with one owner, which is taxed like a sole proprietorship by default, and a multi-member LLC, with more than one owner, which is taxed like a partnership by default. Either can elect to be taxed as an S corporation instead.

LLCs are popular because they’re easy to start and run, and you gain liability protection plus flexible tax options. However, by default the owners pay self-employment tax on their share of the business’s net earnings, which can mean a hefty tax bill as profits grow.

To start an LLC, you file articles of organization with your Secretary of State’s office. If your LLC meets the IRS requirements, you can then file Form 2553 to elect S corp taxation.

What are the main differences?

Business structures cause a lot of confusion among new business owners, so here are the main differences between an S corp and an LLC.

  • A limited liability company (LLC) is a legal business structure that separates your business and personal assets, protecting you from business liabilities.
  • An S corporation (S corp) isn’t a legal structure but a tax election that determines how your business pays federal taxes. The liability protection comes from the LLC or corporation underneath it.
  • LLCs and S corps have different ownership rules, pay structures and reporting requirements, covered below.

1. Ownership

There aren’t any IRS rules restricting LLC ownership, but there are for an S corporation. These are the key differences.

  • An LLC can have unlimited members, while an S corp can have no more than 100 shareholders.
  • LLC members can be non-U.S. citizens or residents. S corp shareholders can’t be nonresident aliens.
  • Individuals, partnerships, corporations or other LLCs can own an LLC. S corp ownership is limited to individuals, certain trusts and estates.
  • An LLC can issue different classes of membership interest. An S corp can have only one class of stock.

2. Management

Management structure refers to who runs a business and how they make high-level and daily decisions.

You can choose one of two management structures for an LLC. Owners can run the business themselves (member-managed), or they can appoint managers (manager-managed).

An LLC that elects S corp taxation keeps its LLC management structure. Only a corporation needs a board of directors elected by the shareholders, which appoints officers to run the business. The S corp election doesn’t change how the business is managed, only how it’s taxed.

3. Self-employment taxes

By default, single-member LLCs pay taxes like sole proprietors, and multi-member LLCs like partnerships. Active owners pay self-employment tax of 15.3% on their net earnings: 12.4% for Social Security, which applies to the first $184,500 of earnings in 2026, and 2.9% for Medicare.

To reduce their self-employment tax bill, single and multi-member LLCs can elect S corp taxation if they meet the IRS eligibility requirements.

S corp shareholders who work in the business are employees and must receive a reasonable salary for their services. Wages are subject to payroll taxes at the same combined 15.3%, but the S corp pays 7.65% and the employee pays the other 7.65%. Shareholders can then receive further payments as distributions, which aren’t subject to payroll taxes.

These are the key differences.

  • LLC owners pay self-employment tax on their share of net earnings.
  • S corp shareholder-employees pay payroll taxes on their salary only, and distributions on top of that aren’t subject to payroll taxes.

The salary must be reasonable for the work you do. The IRS can reclassify distributions as wages if the salary is set too low.

4. Allocation of profits and losses

LLC owners can split business profits and losses between members as they agree in the operating agreement, within IRS rules. For example, a member with a 50% interest could receive 70% of the profits.

In contrast, S corp shareholders receive profits and losses in proportion to their ownership, because an S corp can have only one class of stock.

5. Stock and shareholders

LLCs don’t issue stock and don’t have shareholders. Members hold membership interests, and payments follow the operating agreement.

A corporation taxed as an S corp issues stock, and shareholders vote in proportion to their shares. An LLC taxed as an S corp still has members, but the IRS treats it as a corporation for tax purposes.

6. Business operations

LLC business operations are simpler and have fewer requirements than corporations.

LLCs need an operating agreement, written by their members, and in most states they file annual reports to stay in good standing.

An S corp election adds tax work for any business. The company runs payroll for its owner-employees, files payroll tax returns and files a separate federal return on Form 1120-S. A corporation also has to adopt bylaws, hold annual meetings and keep minutes under state law.

7. Transferability of ownership

Corporate stock is generally transferable, subject to any shareholder agreement. With an S corp, a transfer to an ineligible owner, such as a partnership or a nonresident alien, ends the S corp election, so many S corps restrict transfers in their shareholder agreements.

LLC ownership (a member’s interest) is usually less freely transferable. Under many states’ default rules, a new member needs the approval of the other members unless the operating agreement says otherwise.

The similarities between S corps and LLCs

1. Limited liability protection

An LLC protects its members from personal liability for business debts and claims. An S corp election doesn’t change that, and a corporation taxed as an S corp protects its shareholders in the same way. Owners can lose that protection if a court finds they ignored formalities or mixed personal and business funds, known as piercing the corporate veil (see LLC asset protection).

2. Separate entities

LLCs and corporations are separate legal entities from their owners, who create them by filing with their state.

That said, LLC and corporation formation requirements differ and are governed by different state laws.

3. Pass-through taxation

S corporations and LLCs (by default) are pass-through tax entities. Profits and losses pass through to the members or shareholders, who report them on their tax returns, avoiding federal corporate income tax and double taxation.

LLC vs. S corp pros and cons

Choosing between an S corp and an LLC is a significant decision for business owners. If your LLC earns steady profits and you don’t consider the S corp election, you could miss out on tax savings.

But if it were that simple, every entrepreneur would elect S corp status. There are pros and cons to weigh.

S corp pros

  • Payroll taxes apply only to the owner’s reasonable salary, not to distributions, which can lower the total tax bill for profitable businesses.
  • Profits pass through to the owners, so the business avoids federal corporate income tax and double taxation.
  • Owners may qualify for the qualified business income deduction of up to 20%, which 2025 legislation made permanent. LLC owners can claim it too, but an S corp owner’s salary doesn’t count toward it.
  • Limited liability protection stays in place, because it comes from the LLC or corporation.

S corp cons

  • More work and cost to run, including payroll, quarterly payroll filings, a separate Form 1120-S return and often higher accounting fees.
  • Strict ownership rules: no more than 100 shareholders, no nonresident alien or entity owners, and only one class of stock.
  • Less flexibility, because profits must be split in proportion to ownership.
  • Some states and cities tax S corps at the entity level or don’t fully recognize the election, so check with your state’s tax agency.
  • The tax savings may be small or negative for businesses with low or uneven profits once the extra costs are counted.

LLC pros

  • Like an S corp, single and multi-member LLCs are separate legal entities from their owners. Limited liability protects the owners’ personal assets from lawsuits and business debts, and creditors can generally only pursue assets belonging to the business.
  • LLCs are easier to start and operate than a corporation, and they don’t need payroll for the owners.
  • An LLC passes its profits and losses to the owners, who report them on their tax returns, avoiding corporate income tax.
  • LLCs have a flexible structure, which is popular with small business owners. There are no limits on the number of owners, members can be non-U.S. citizens or residents, and you can run the LLC yourself or appoint a manager.
  • An LLC can elect S corp taxation later if its profits grow.

LLC cons

  • By default, active owners pay self-employment tax on all of their share of net earnings.
  • LLCs aren’t ideal for venture capital. Most venture investors prefer a C corporation, and an S corp can’t take on entity or foreign investors either (see LLC vs. corporation).
  • LLCs have start-up and ongoing fees, including the costs of filing articles of organization, annual reports and, if you don’t act as your own, a registered agent. Some states also charge an annual franchise tax or fee (see LLC costs).

How to choose a structure that is right for you

Many small business owners don’t begin with an S corp. Instead, they move from a sole proprietorship or partnership to an LLC as their business grows, and elect S corp taxation when their income makes the tax savings worth the extra cost.

Timing is important with an S corp election. Form 2553 is generally due within 2 months and 15 days after the start of the tax year the election is to take effect, and switching back and forth can have tax consequences. Talk to a CPA before you elect.

To choose a structure suitable for your business, think about your profits, whether you’ll pay yourself a regular salary, and the tax and administrative costs of each option.

  • An LLC with default taxation suits entrepreneurs starting a business on a smaller budget who need liability protection, want flexibility and want to keep administration simple.
  • An LLC taxed as an S corp suits owners with steady profits who work in the business, can pay themselves a reasonable salary and want to reduce their self-employment tax.

Which one should you choose?

Forming an LLC is the next logical step for many partnerships and sole proprietors. It formalizes the business and provides limited liability, protecting the owners’ personal assets from litigation and debt.

The S corp election is a tax decision you can make once your LLC’s profits make it worthwhile. Your choice depends on your business income, how you plan to pay yourself and your future goals. Because you form an LLC first and can add the S corp election later, starting with an LLC keeps your options open. See how an LLC compares with other structures in the LLC comparisons guide.

FAQ

What is the difference between an LLC and an S corporation?

An LLC is a legal business structure that provides liability protection, while an S corporation is a federal tax election that changes how a business’s profits are taxed.

Is an S corporation better than an LLC for taxes?

It can be. An S corp can reduce self-employment tax by splitting income into a salary and distributions, but payroll and extra filings add costs, so it usually pays off only with steady profits.

Can an LLC choose to be taxed as an S corporation?

Yes. An LLC can elect S corporation taxation by filing IRS Form 2553 if it meets the eligibility requirements, including no more than 100 eligible shareholders and one class of stock.

Do LLCs and S corporations offer the same liability protection?

Yes. The S corp election doesn’t change liability protection, which comes from the LLC or corporation. Owners keep it as long as they follow legal formalities and keep finances separate.

Which is better for a small business: LLC or S corporation?

An LLC with default taxation is often best for new or smaller businesses because it’s simple. Electing S corp taxation may be better once profits are steady enough to justify payroll costs.

LLC related articles